Baking soda vs baking powderā¦.what is the difference? Iām here to teach you the basics of each so that you can improve your baking skills. Learn the whys, hows, and when theyāre important to achieving delicious recipes.
Baking powder and baking soda are key ingredients in so many classic recipes! Baking soda is a must when baking cookies. Sometimes I use both, like in our favorite copycat Crumbl cookie recipe. And I couldnāt make my homemade pancake mix without the help of baking powder because it makes them SO fluffy!
Reasons to Know How They Work
- Improve Your Baking: The wrong use of baking powder and baking soda can affect your baking.
- Learn When to Use Them: Improve your baking game and know when and why to use them in your recipes.
- Best Baking Results: Get the best baking results by balancing flavors and achieving the perfect texture and shape of baked goods.
Baking Soda vs Baking Powder
Baking soda and baking powder are both chemical leavening agents. The ingredient in a recipe makes dough or batter rise through a chemical reaction. However, they are NOT the same! They have notable differences, so letās compare baking soda vs baking powder and break it down!
What is Baking Soda?
Baking soda is powerful! It is 3 times stronger than baking powder! In the world of science, baking soda is known as a base. It will create a reaction when it comes in contact with an acid. This also translates into the world of baking! This reaction produces a carbon dioxide gas, and the bubbles from this reaction give a light texture in baked goods. Recipes that use baking soda will also call for some type of acid to create this chemical reaction.
Acids That React With Baking Soda
Weāre all familiar with the reaction of baking soda and vinegar but many ingredients react in recipes to create carbon dioxide. Here is a list of acid ingredients commonly used in baking:
- Vinegar
- Citrus Juices
- Buttermilk
- Sour Cream or Yogurt
- Cocoa Powder (Not Dutch Process)
- Brown sugar
- Cream of Tartar
- Molasses or Honey
Irish Soda Bread is a bread recipe that relies on the reaction of buttermilk and baking soda to rise. My fun Wacky Cake is another example of this reaction. The baking soda and vinegar in the recipe give this cake the fluffiest texture and itās SO yummy!
Too Much Baking Soda?
Using too much baking soda in your recipes without neutralizing it with an acid will result in a strong metallic flavor from the baking soda. Some people might think the more baking soda you use the more rise youāll get, but that isnāt how baking soda works. It needs to be just the right amount and has to have an acid to react and neutralize it.
What is Baking Powder?
Baking powder actually has baking soda in it! It also contains another acid like cream of tartar or cornstarch that helps neutralize the baking soda. This means there isnāt a need for another acid for baking powder to react. Baking powder reacts in two different ways, and if youāve ever wondered why the container says ādouble-actingā, hereās why:
- Moisture: Baking powder first becomes active when it gets wet. Air bubbles are created when it comes in contact with water, milk, or any moisture in the recipe. This is why most recipes need to be baked right away while the chemicals are still active.
- Heat: Baking powder also becomes active when itās exposed to heat during the baking process. As the ingredients reach a certain temperature, the baking powder creates lift and helps the baked goods rise and become fluffy!
My Grandmaās Perfect Fluffy Pancakes are the perfect example of this reaction. The baking powder in her pancake recipe reacts with the heat of the skillet making them fluffy and soft! Another example is this delicious Ricotta Cake! The baking powder makes it so light and fluffy as it bakes.
Why Use Both?
It is necessary to use both baking soda and baking powder in certain recipes! Using both can improve the texture and the flavor of your baked goods. Itās fun to see what happens when you use either baking soda, baking powder, or both! Check out the results below!
- Improve Texture: Some recipes use both to improve the texture. Baking soda alone doesnāt lend enough rise to some recipes. Instead of just adding more baking soda, which will only lead to a sour metallic taste, you add baking powder to give extra lift.Ā My Twinkie Cake uses bothĀ and the texture is fluffy and delicious!
- Flavor: Using both can also improve the flavor of your recipes. Sometimes you need both because you want the tang of an acid in your recipe to come through in the finished product. If you only rely on baking soda for rise, it will neutralize the flavor of the acid youāre using. Using both allows the tangy acidic flavor of say buttermilk or lemon juice to come through.Ā Try this Glazed Lemon Bread and youāll see what I mean!
Can You Substitute One For the Other?
In short, I wouldnāt recommend it! Itās tricky to do without affecting the rise, texture, and flavor of your baked good. Itās better to follow a recipe the way it is written to get the best results!
Does Baking Powder and Baking Soda Expire?
Yes, they expire! Here are some tips for storing and keeping baking powder and baking soda fresh!
- In the Cupboard: It is best to store baking soda and baking powder in an airtight container. Baking powder already comes in an airtight container, but baking soda should be removed from the cardboard box and stored in an airtight container. Store them both in a dry, cool place like a cupboard. Storing in the Refrigerator is not recommended.
- Expiration Tips: Itās helpful to write the date you open them on the container. Store unopened baking soda at room temperature for 18 months. After opening, store at room temperature for 6 months. Store unopened baking powder at room temperatureĀ for 6 months. After opening, store at room temperature for 3 months!
- How to Test the Freshness of Baking Powder: Add about Ā¼ cup of warm water to a bowl along with 1 tablespoon of baking powder. Stir the mixture and it should become a bit fizzy. If there isnāt any fizz then itās bad.
- How to Test the Freshness of Baking Soda: For baking soda, itās the same test, but instead of warm water, use plain white vinegar. The mixture will be very fizzy and bubbly when itās fresh. If it isnāt very active then your baking soda has gone bad.
Recipes Using Baking Soda or Baking Powder!
